Camping Mastery
Menu
  • Home
  • Tents
    • 1 Person
    • 2 Person
    • 3 Person
    • 4 Person
    • 5 Person
    • 6 Person
    • 8 Person
    • 9 Person
    • 10 Person
    • 12 Person
  • Tents I love
  • Sleeping Bags
  • Tent Camping
    • Beginners
    • Family Camping
    • Tips
  • Solo Camping
    • Men
    • Women
  • Hiking
Menu

The Kelty Yellowstone 4 Tent Needs A Tarp Or It Will Leak (Review)

Posted on March 17, 2017 by Brandon

Why exactly has this tent not received the “good” reviews that it should be receiving, but most especially why hasn’t it had many purchases at all? Is it because it isn’t good enough?

I just came across this tent on Amazon.com and it caught my eye, mostly because it doesn’t have many purchases, but it really looks like a great tent!

In my Kelty Yellowstone 4 Tent review, I will discover if this tent is worth purchasing or not even worth looking into.

Not Many Features!
  • Functionality
  • Waterproof
  • Strength
  • Worth The Price?
3.6

Summary:

Some people have found this tent to work good for them, but there is just too many complaints for a tent of this price. The stakes aren’t the best and rain has been found to leak through the floor, so you will need a tarp or footprint if you don’t want to take that gamble.


Kelty Yellowstone 4 Tent

 Pros Cons
  • The rain fly and body is really fast and easy to set up due to the quick-clip system
  • It has been found to stand strong in high winds – as claimed by many users
  • It compacts down into a really small package, making it easy to stow away when travelling
  • This tent has a flimsy fabric bottom and has been known to leak when it rains. A tarp or footprint protector is a MUST, especially you’re expecting rain
  • Because there’s one window on the door, it makes for a very hot day when the rain fly is on
  • The 2-zipper system makes a basic function really awkward. It leaves a gap at the bottom of the door for insects to get through
  • A lot of users don’t like the stakes that come with this tent.

price-button

Or Check Out This Better Tent Out

Specifications


Product name: Kelty Yellowstone 4 Tent

Cheapest Place To Buy: Amazon.com

Color: Grey/Green

The Kelty Yellowstone 4 Tent Stuff Sack

Size: 4-person

Rating: 3-season

Minimum Weight: 7 lb 10 oz

Packaged Weight: 8 lb 10 oz

Center Height: 4.9 feet

Floor Size: 7.5 x 6.7 feet

Floor Area: 55 Sq. ft

Packed Size: 7 x 23 inches

Footprint Included: No

Gear Loft Included: No

Product Description


This has tent has been described from the manufacturers to have many “high quality” features, while the massive D-shaped door allows for much easier entry and exit – especially when camping with 3 or more people.

It has a freestanding design, which is very economical due to the eco-friendly poles.

The rain fly creates an awning, allowing you to keep the door open even in a downpour.

There are mesh panels on the sides of the walls and roof to maximize ventilation – reducing condensation.

The Awning Over The Door

Awning Over Window

It has “continuous” pole sleeves at the peak and along along the sides (with clips), meaning it is very easy and quick to setup.

The seams come up and off the ground due to Keltys Arc Edge feature, making sure it stays away from all the ground moisture that gets built up overnight.

Entry and Exit


There is one door only. However, this door is very large as you can clearly see from the pictures above.

Because of the size of it, it makes it easier for two people to walk in and out at the same time without getting in the way.

There was a complaint about the 2-zipper system. Instead of having 1 continuous track, they have gone and made 2 separate tracks entirely.

I’m not 100% sure why they did this, because it leaves a small gap at the bottom of the door – where insects can get in!

Storage


Sadly, this tent doesn’t have a vestibule area.

But it still contains lots of interior storage pockets.

One of them is I-pad compatible, so you can put your electronics in them, while this tent also contains a bunch of other storage pockets as well – AND gear loft loops.

Keep in mind: The gear loft loops are there, but the gear loft is sold separately.

Ventilation


The Ventilation – Mesh Panels On Roof And Walls

Kelty Yellowstone 4 Tent Without Rain Fly

This type of ventilation is pretty good in my honest opinion.

Because of the panels on the walls, it gives ventilation at the BOTTOM of the tent, and the panels on the roof offers ventilation at the TOP.

This distributes an even high/low amount of air flow throughout the entire tent to stop condensation buildup.

Weatherproofing


It offers a fully taped construction (stops leaks), along with the raised seams to give it even more protection from the rain.

The floor and seams are described as “tough and durable”, while being VERY waterproof.

The rain fly comes all the way to the ground, which is what I always like to see.

Even when it’s raining you can leave the door open due to the awning, I like that.

What I Like About This Tent


The very large door is nice. Usually when you have a lot of people camping in a tent, thoroughfare can get quite annoying when everyone’s going in and out at once.

You will not have that problem with this tent.

The awning is a nice touch as well.

If you’re like me, you absolutely HATE getting rained on when you open up the tent for the day and all the water just falls down and onto your head.

What I Don’t Like


I’m not really a big fan at the moment, since there’s no vestibule area.

Vestibules are becoming more and more popular, and if Kelty are going to skimp over this feature whenever they feel like it, they are missing out on a great finisher (and possibly buyers, too)

I don’t like how there’s only 1 door. But again, I guess the large D-door makes up for it.

It will just get annoying when somebodies trying to get out for a midnight pit stop.

Who Should Buy This Tent?


Due to it being on the heavier side of tents (8.10 pounds w/rain fly) and because it doesn’t have a vestibule room, it is BEST used for car camping.

However, if you wish to go backpacking with this tent, you will definitely need 2 people – minimum.

This is so you can split the weight up between the 2 of you, AND have spare room to store your gear overnight.

Best Place To Buy?


Amazon.com is my preferred choice to shop for tents, for the fact that they have fast deliveries, free shipping, and even a 30-day return policy.

With Amazon, you can get a full refund if you decide you don’t want the product anymore (a good choice if it wasn’t up to your expectations), while you can get a repair if you find any defects on the product as well.

price-button

Do I Recommend Kelty Yellowstone 4 Tent?


Since you can get better tents in this price range, but mostly because you’re going to need a footprint, or a tarp at the very least if you want to stay dry in the rain, I’m not liking the odds so far.

It has ONE door only, and it doesn’t even contain a vestibule room.

I’ll make it simple and to the point.

The Kelty Yellowstone 4 Tent has way too many negative reviews and it doesn’t even get the basics of a tent right either, so I have to give this question an easy no.

Not recommended.

Alternative Tent


The Kelty Grand Mesa 4 Tent weighs a little less and costs a little bit more. However, most of the buyers have nothing but nice things to say about it – and I know why, because it DOESN’T leak, it has good stakes, and it has a vestibule room so every camper has somewhere to put their equipment!

Another great alternative is the Slumberjack 4 Person Trail Tent – which is much heavier than both tents mentioned, but it is also in the same price range as the Kelty Yellowstone, and performs a lot better in the rain as well.

My Final Opinion


There are so many flaws that this tent has, while it doesn’t even provide that many features to begin with.

Even though it has an awning, there is no vestibule, only 1 door, AND no stargazing opportunities either since your view is very limited.

Since there are much better options within the same price range, I would have to give this tent a thumbs down.

The verdict? Not recommended!

Check Out The Kelty Grand Mesa 4 Tent Instead

Not Many Features!
  • Functionality
  • Waterproof
  • Strength
  • Worth The Price?
3.6

Summary:

Some people have found this tent to work good for them, but there is just too many complaints for a tent of this price. The stakes aren’t the best and rain has been found to leak through the floor, so you will need a tarp or footprint if you don’t want to take that gamble.

10 thoughts on “The Kelty Yellowstone 4 Tent Needs A Tarp Or It Will Leak (Review)”

  1. Jean says:
    March 17, 2017 at 4:41 pm

    Nice review. Me and my girlfriend love camping but is more often just the two of us so this tent will be perfectly sized. We do however do a lot of camping in the rainy season so the waterproofing mite be a issue. We are currently using a 4-man canvas test which is great. It is high enough to stand in and is very robust. It’s major downfall is it is very heavy and takes a lot of space in the car. That’s why we are looking at getting something along the lines of this kind of tent.

    Reply
    1. Brandon says:
      March 19, 2017 at 11:50 am

      If you go car camping often, weight doesn’t have to be an issue.

      However, if the tent is taking up too much space, then I agree, it might be time to upgrade to something better. IF you do decide to get this one, make sure you purchase the footprint, or even a tarp will work just fine.

      Reply
  2. Adriana says:
    March 17, 2017 at 5:05 pm

    This seems like a cool tent but it is on the pricier side for what it offers. The other one you mention is decent but it is heavier. Is there any other one that may be a little lighter and offer more stargazing opportunities? Would the price be ridiculous or decently understandable? Thank you for the awesome review!

    Reply
    1. Brandon says:
      March 19, 2017 at 12:02 pm

      Absolutely, Adriana. However, there’s not really much to choose from in the lower price bracket if you’re trying to go ultralight – not for a 4 person tent anyway.

      There is one that’s much pricier but offers exactly what you’re looking for – the Copper Spur UL4 tent.

      If you want stargazing opportunities but in the lower price range and still lightweight, you have to drop down a size or two. I highly recommend the Grand Mesa 2 tent!

      Reply
  3. Azaro says:
    March 17, 2017 at 8:11 pm

    Hey Brandon. What a good review. We have bought this tent before. I wish I had read your review before buying it. The first day we used it, it was raining. You can just imagine the disappointment. When buying our next tent I will definitely check out your reviews. Some amazon reviews can be misleading.

    Reply
    1. Brandon says:
      March 19, 2017 at 12:08 pm

      Hey Azaro!

      Thanks for the comment. You are right, there are so many misleading Amazon reviews on the internet. I know what it’s like to receive a bad tent after somebody praises the hell out of it, which is why I provide honest opinions on all of my reviews.

      Cheers,
      Brandon

      Reply
  4. Wenda says:
    March 20, 2017 at 9:35 pm

    I’m glad I read your review, this tent look FINE to me, but after reading your pros and cons, I realized that unless I was prepared with ground cover I could risk problems if it rained, plus… the 2 zipper system. I never though about that little tiny gap 2 zippers would leave. That’s all that’s needed for the mosquitoes to get in! Thanks for the great review.

    Reply
    1. Brandon says:
      March 27, 2017 at 2:47 pm

      Hi Wenda. The 2-zipper system is just a waste of time and doesn’t offer any decent functionality in my honest opinion. All it does is allows bugs to get in! Kelty have really let me down with this tent, but luckily this is only one of the few that they have created badly.

      What made it even worse was that water can make its way into the tent from the ground!

      Most of their tents are usually really good, so I’ll still be getting their tents, I just have to do more research now.

      Reply
  5. Ronnie Jordan says:
    March 21, 2017 at 1:06 pm

    Very good review as always Brandon. I thought it looked really nice and I too liked the awning on it. But you sound like you know what you are talking about so I’m with you on this one. Forget getting leaked on. Thanks for the information.

    Reply
    1. Brandon says:
      March 21, 2017 at 3:39 pm

      Thanks for the kind words, Ronnie. I’ve had enough bad experiences with getting rain water inside my tent. I am NOT having anymore of those episodes!

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

  • Where Can You See Beautiful Fall Foliage While Hiking On The East Coast?
  • Backyard Family Camping – The Ultimate Guide
  • The Ultimate Guide to Tentsile Tree Tents
  • The Ultimate Family Camping List
  • Super Sparrow Water Bottle Review
  • 5 Awesome Water Bottles to Take Outdoors
  • Hydro Flask 32oz. Wide Mouth Review
  • Nalgene 32oz Wide Mouth Water Bottle Review
  • Platypus Platy 2.0L Flexible Water Bottle Review
  • Klean Kanteen 20oz. Insulated Classic Review

Categories

  • 1 Person
  • 10 Person
  • 12 Person
  • 2 Person
  • 3 Person
  • 4 Person
  • 5 Person
  • 6 Person
  • 8 Person
  • 9 Person
  • Backpacks
  • Beginners
  • Boots
  • Camping Hammocks
  • Camping On A Budget
  • Family Camping
  • Gear
  • General Camping
  • Getting Started
  • Hacks
  • Hiking
  • Knives
  • Meals
  • Men
  • RV Camping
  • Sleeping Bags
  • Solo Camping
  • Survival
  • Tent Camping
  • Tents
  • Tips
  • Tips and Tricks
  • Uncategorized
  • Water Bottles
  • Winter Camping
  • Women

Archives

  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • July 2020
  • September 2019
  • July 2019
  • June 2019
  • May 2019
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • June 2018
  • May 2018
  • April 2018
  • March 2018
  • December 2017
  • November 2017
  • October 2017
  • September 2017
  • August 2017
  • July 2017
  • June 2017
  • May 2017
  • April 2017
  • March 2017
  • February 2017
  • January 2017
  • December 2016
  • November 2016
  • October 2016
  • September 2016
  • August 2016
  • July 2016

About Camping Mastery

Contact
About Me
Privacy Policy

Logo

Travel graphic by Freepik from Flaticon
is licensed under CC BY 3.0. Made with Logo Maker

Affiliate Disclosure

campingmastery.com participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

©2025 Camping Mastery | Built using WordPress and Responsive Blogily theme by Superb